Rigby & Peller Madison & 90th St

Rigby & Peller's Madison Avenue and 90th Street location is the Upper East Side counterpart to the chain's Magnificent Mile Chicago store. Recent reviews lean heavily on multiple specific fitters named glowingly across the recent wall, one in particular has reportedly been at the boutique for 19+ years and handled a 13-year-old's first proper bra fitting with respect and privacy. Another named fitter is repeatedly called out for sizing customers correctly by eye. Post-pregnancy, post-weight-loss, and out-of-town visit fittings come up repeatedly. A Boston customer specifically traveled for a fitting. With a 4.8 rating, the only meaningful caveat is luxury pricing (treated as worth it for the quality and longevity). Best for UES shoppers wanting world-class bra fitting, and for special occasions like first bras for teenagers, post-baby fittings, or post-weight-loss size resets.