FANTASY PARTY NYC

★ 4.0 · 92 reviews

333 6th Ave, New York, NY 10014

Women Men Couples Adult toys Lingerie Adult costumes Couples toys Novelty gifts Lubricants & oils No shapewear & fajas No dancewear No bondage & kink gear No fetishwear No adult media (dvds, magazines) No smoking accessories No cbd & vape

Our take

Editorial

FANTASY PARTY NYC on 6th Avenue in the West Village is unusual for this directory: the storefront combines adult novelty retail (lingerie, party goods, toys) with a piercing and tattoo parlor. The hybrid model shows up in the reviews, recent positive comments cluster around piercings done well by named artists, while the dense negative wall is dominated by tattoo and piercing complaints: tattoos faded within a week or a month, piercings falling out within 2 hours from being screwed in incorrectly, a specific artist named for going 'way too deep' on a tattoo that doesn't match, and customers turned away for closed-during-posted-hours touch-up appointments. The retail-only side gets mixed reviews, knowledgeable staff but elevated prices, and one customer reports a $54 toy that didn't work out of the box. Best for piercings specifically (ask for a named artist with positive reviews), and for visitors comfortable with the cheaper-but-riskier tattoo posture; not the place for a high-stakes retail purchase.

What customers say

Summarized from 92 reviews

Customers love

Specific piercers named glowingly for sterile process, well-aligned placement, and patient walk-throughs
Late hours convenient for after-work or after-bar visits
Pricing reportedly cheaper than competitors for piercing and tattoo work
Walk-in friendly with same-day availability
Retail-side selection covers lingerie, bachelorette party goods, and toys

Customers caution

Multiple recent reviewers report tattoos fading within a week to a month, including a $130 small tattoo requiring three failed touch-up visits to a closed store
A specific tattoo artist is named for going 'way too deep,' resulting in tattoos that don't match
Piercings reportedly falling out within 2 hours from being screwed in incorrectly
Staff described as rude, one reviewer reports being told to leave for no reason
A customer reports a $54 toy that didn't work out of the box with new batteries

The themes above are summarized from public customer reviews published on third-party platforms (including Google Maps). They represent the opinions of those reviewers, not the opinions or positions of Sex Shop Maps. Names and specific experiences described are reproduced from public reviews. If you are referenced in any content on this page and would like it removed, see our removals process.

More stores in New York

See all 94 stores →